MTA vs. antivir, MS vs. unix

yce yce na seznam.cz
Čtvrtek Duben 25 12:33:21 CEST 2002


Posilam neco k precteni.
Neni to vec do teto konference,
ktera ma resit problematiku MTA.
Kodova stranka je v proklete Windoze.
Ale stoji to za to.
Fakt.
Doufam, ze mi prominete.

Petr

----- Original Message -----
From: "Petr Simek" <psimek na jcu.cz>
To: <sendmail na linux.cz>
Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2002 11:46 AM
Subject: Re: MTA vs. antivir (Re: Postfix a mailertable)


> On Thu, 25 Apr 2002, Lubos Kaspar wrote:
>
> > To je demagogie nahravajici jen tomu, aby si lide jeste vic narazili na
> > oci MS-klapky. Srovnavat spamy a MS-viry je jako scitat povestna jablka
> > s hruskami. Spam je zalezitost nezavisla na platforme MUA, kdezto
> > MS-vir ohrozuje jen OS, kde bezi MUA, tj. MS-Win-XX.
>
> Myslim ze mate klapky na ocich - MS vir ktery ma 150Kb a rozesila se
stylem
> one-to-many zatezuje MTA a linky organizaci a tim jejich schopnost sitove
> a SMTP komunikace. Je nanejvys zadouci takovy datovy tok likvidovat a
> nejlepe v centru kterym musi projit -> MTA. Nejde tu jen o pohodli a
bezpeci
> uzivatelu MS, ale o dobrou funkcnost site a SMTP sluzby
>
> > > drivejsi negativa prichazi i ted obranna reakce a je dost
pravedepodobne
> > > ze za par let uz se to do maileru nebude muset 'dodelavat' ale budou k
tomu
> > > samy uzpusobeny aby slo jednoduse zapojit antivirovou kontrolu do
procesu
> > > prenosu a zpracovani posty.
> >
> > Ano, to je typicka predstava MS-pohunka. Proc by se mela vsude premilat
>
> Ty osobni invektivy svedci spis o Vasi hlouposti.
>
> > posta a prosivat MS-viry, kdyz jinym MUA nez pod MS-OS nevadi? Proc si
> > sve viry nechyta sam MS-Outlook/Exchange? Krome toho treba mne se vubec
> > nelibi takova cenzura posty. Pokud by se obecne prijala takova "vize"
> > fizlovani obsahu zasilek, je treba si dobre uvedomit, jakou moc by meli
> > vyrobci antiviru: uplne "legalne" by mohli sledovat obsah
"kontrolovanych"
> > zprav! Dekuji pekne, nechci. Proto je zahodno posilat (aspon
dulezitejsi)
> > zpravy zasifrovane, pak jsou antiviry nahrane.
>
> Pokud by se posilaly pouze sifrovane zpravy, jsou nahrane predevsim viry
> nebot zasifrovany virus ktery se neda 'rozsifrovat' a spustit nikoho
> neohrozi a nemuze se dal sirit. Antiviry by pak nebyly potreba.
>
> >                                                 Lubos Kaspar
> >
>
> *------------------------------------------------------------------------*
> |                          Petr Simek   APS JU                           |
> |                             psimek na jcu.cz                              |
> *------------------------------------------------------------------------*
>
>


begin 666 MS.zip
M4$L#!!0``@`(`*%CF2SBAPK6?Q(``/TB```&````35,N='ATW5I-;]M(MMT'
MR'\H:Q. na H58OWBX;(W%ZT).TX[S8[1YD5Q(K5HD?19!53,@?,3] P.CW].:M
MWF:VW$F B %Z-DH#`MXYMRC;Z9?W!UZC`=L2BZRZ]]QSS[G,!UT;M:I-KD*R
MSW2F%LMV'F9/G[QTV:#RO?).!97OED[E.N./NDIVVU3CDG<N=56Q5[A#FNEB
MR%5Y,(FZ;FN_RTT^5:DWU5&5+G1&U6%ME.L*G8>5>8[%E;NK-)94KC%)I na I3
M9MH7+BA7FDHOK-)J'A*C0NJ*K2GPO!>+Y51Y?.PR4WM5Z$15KN.VN:S$HN'^
M*E.H. na _>I/PD,UB6\BAYJ <U/WI\^IJ'KO/A8(JCJI6K\; <#UUGN na QJGO7>
M-L?<JI!9'!>_I$9UI6OVB<7J7S:VT=YDPS9US4YM[&I8#*HYK5LL59V%W.!G
M8Q,$<H>MA na 7"5[C&+HS23Y^$VH<RK ;5J07.T^*ND^LL++5ZUR.J+VV6Z;.G
M3]Z:4B>Z<3CQRN &25C;LPFCS["N3,*C>GT84B8BJ3;<1NJ"3\-,759Z.^#S
MF?J[4?-6O=9S;KD_G,>P%&:J;)$VMN.F5G:CDKXIG&K6V'KQZ'KDH>PSFS'O
MDPM na Q#4`"X$S55=^:]0[W61F-N$9L-],>3L"8:KJM na CG^.8-`I94?::Q:_7'
M1M=%_US=M,HA:-NT!7HL3U+Y(&E.JQY7J-QAC7+IL4CU].D38JI7JX1 \:89
M*NVGJM/C+[DM+'!J.VR/?^K/#W_.9MC[;;Q3C\2L:MSCT15]P:U4NFM5C<N1
M0\#TFK\A#(OT`<X1]5N3(@*%CEM6O]HB<9_J*1"$<WB'@LH/)E/+3"?M]'2C
M&W=?%D1DDKE 3"!)'C>K?=47:0`@/GWZ-,OMHG*U^^AG"ZQZ^D1O),$``BY-
MG/KQL^\[(Z>:7 #:5E4Z&;R)"3G'IE.5]SF",\=MK5>7B.1.7>>5M_>!S N6
MY na 8UJ9("^+<`Z&)@MB8H[[X8IDQ 9OV\G:KWQA9\NEZ8,\DTSM0__O1<?0"^
MPVD'OZR-/WBB;.F20LBC1< *LUJZ:CTLG=SE=EA'C$S5Q na CL6<N-S9X3W98$
M(T ZA5CE`\!%;ECCZ!?+A5FKFF3 na DM)5S+3BQG;J1?"NLGZO;@#FZU#B6Q_.
MY9DW#M7 (L5Y;9JTV%/B&@> QZ^9&S<_F+BQF7IE:N,!2,\5G5Y6>J6N<;G7
MMC),.:BK7\0K+BV A/KV3<]B-9'&W-:N_;[0,_4:5;;I$0]5]DG+Y_T\S'LR
M82VTQ;V3;L.&=Q9N!DF6@<N9]V:_14R0U:Q?@+MP"E#40EWND00$Y.F35U58
M'A5Y`7EW)/&FPQY0O J0KTV2:B![<BF%50,.4[ ^6&]KSM3#AV"1'$%/7+X_
M5\#7:2-D:RT`>=V/'SH^3X na -ITOVGBA5IVIOOPH_@#<F%;VBCB2'JU>)P:H4
M+-P,.-0P$X(#GFTD&06:!'T#.9DIUP,*Q\2F!#IV^8 XU?&W2*+MVF1CZ%RB
MYCV8+W4@^OX`FBGV*YWN4/EW=H&?'UV5!]P.1P.LTLRD1? #"E9 %X324$J[
M4J?G$^DA#/YJ`&LX/.V:Q#EO\;BMJ4A7N*U1WRL<TJ,B1BB^-W<6U:VWQ:!>
M::_GJ%Q<U.FT[_H"8$F+_69 "7\5*]5L`$T4?;,&( N]SA""_<(A7PY1S]U2
MMC!YZ\ ""C#>$)XE&@MH0/F#C7C$1ANIY*31\LE;,"=(FIS"$@-<(V;1Z;U#
M4-%+>L\F_>S"^A8$L)+P(!W%;JI^=2E0!;:H4]9RC3L5YAEN1D:K6>UNOC(-
M.]O;V-1W8T^7_G"Q]/N'I+K2%9&K-R8R,B(\U_,:F6&SK4 [&MG!L]<VKBH`
M]L(<3)JQ_!W/C?R"5TBZR$2,D7!(TH*$8 na IPK#&C:HMX[-/[PF\&J9I;+D="
M`+#(ZTF#AZ@/J*,]R1^BXTZ/*$?,/R2Z$OC.U(?,HH,F[(A6)3I;L^.F'K0Q
MDA/E1Z[R"G$+7DKGT>I7Y!F%OK-88L5MBP8TY!*IG[]TR(].7<0!TNI"R2IF
MHRR1?),$;A3 ,%%>L/YO3.%=I"IV=)(<D8VPD(3WA*S41PQFH[I>=,BI+$ $
M=4MZ>(%&I[.VK/69>E4AM:^NKOGDQ;+OH%G*WJ<MY,GU@ I_!\1HM%!&^9]]
M na A:&9[MR[PF;.87*:B#1O36HTOU)-R!)`-9I[9$K31K3':HMB=O+%9).V3QT
M7<X^@D.\83Z0#/!,CL,U]M17^60L02[SH0!]-/@$LJ _L.D5NM0'BS0M3'9$
M)=?#`B7?K[$2E=GL.\,Z*0]#34FIZ]1TEES>]=BC`NWCJM*Q6V^=J+REJ2B6
M1?7M* 6*-FYDIS*F#]RX&0`,C:Z%_)%.TR]3PK1530M)90H*/^EZ@,XT]K^F
MTT#&-4"$;0.4K"+NNB//86-X*C<&#8I*SD>)VQ# DE0TJ&P'#180_=I3DY<H
M0.RAZ^>0SJF:#U'*-WLOBNX-VL(`08,^5 na X5#BZP0 na S_]GULNM.H<CXCA#_,
M;?'#7-?+&4E'4\>8Y^J'4%?R#0J==?F3-1#X6?NQC5N2MEGJ7'N6R30^" ^T
M2W1>I$IOJ:88KPS\RSN\)1Y'/IV.@)!"!6#6?I#^MDI"A-E7VOP2/6Z$M\9S
M%U&M na F(*,W?_('_'+D<EA(,VN%O#LNJH7;!>- R1*U!'"]0-;I6BFJL^#]^4
MZ>K_4NG7HLP?83-'$[ (`''=$DV'`5FPS7ZU)@]=>T "H8)Y6=OL&*LA&2 E
MR*Q T7X:*2%2GI2&*%%NZZLD3+Y7:U-Z"(NX9V@:4"SH' EKD;K)J%VQ/01.
M0:T`:O!3:6-\IOZH\WTS&UD1CT;APPEL",*Y!0F na UF?J"L+2GSJT`+-T'<0Q
MHH"2(:^?]/%N'@5-/ ]E3I?;SF0/AQ%IJSJ#[%#MP$)(LK_E-:++H.);4;\9
MU-B:/>6O!<O8>"CC,G.5J8!6J QDK=%;=?GN/X"OOU[\)_94]1UJT'1S)*\8
M4HI"Z:,6+&^;\2E@)L.2I40.<[?<B5*_1\N#4IJ-BK(PY!!Q3FC1C?U75(]B
MUBJ'=J-!$="!"LV^,]+/V7]64 ;.AU%OC;P^9BQ6#PN-/_F<BRN>>BH]X*K)
M^@2N%SQ4ZL)DAM;WXNI\\G na Q#>@^DUH5PQ>%^_[ B-<-^V&I:W\\V'@,S2OA
MOMC!])1_-! VFM^]U"O?QB:M:77E3])MA($=Q;)<VF;L>5P^5CI_+;#!^^8?
M\8RN0WBC.ITT;/0A6AK<PQ_Z^N'2TI&R$1^L-Z/CJ5$K[M3XY3'(I/J %CX4
M/:\$(J(Q&1Y[%ZK%#UBY= %/.F<XY$;C?K\N(K !`&UI3T'[`,8B6ET&B-6R
M'M!.VKBAC8GFXJL[/$#VN^^^(Z(O2,0B&"FZ$XO2UN*0:F^+HI^)3U8U^*V!
MSW$+S7BG;@M+SV4(/"#B0*-<(*VC3D.)>UQYL^#>3":1L1R0@&_0R$8PL<>>
M>'?UR/E$@*@K*-RP8L\M"?K]B(<_+1,!]G@=K_HISR5V(M$[5 %=JBA\4/(6
MY#8EV\"W96 /;G>J)C@?B!L=E3%;-W9YIB8GAW?'`9"N9_\/OWGG%-2MRQK1
MY,I7X)APLBIF+90(@]@M")/1-*)]4#B,W4EO]:F[T;:X4W^;<9;"S$=C>:XN
M.>Q";029-9SJ:W[TYS*["PF;4-0;:Y.[18%V`^[=CCH\" >T8OXXMS,%98SG
M_RL8G;7]6&G<Z4WB!)?^?@YU+L3]$VBL7[/3%_TVA9E9R@?X$D(2AX>M" GU
MR3?4(_;%Q[,7SM!:P8XES-M,_0:J["/![#?8:[N=LJ.QP_1JJRN7[%>P!^9L
MHJX2[+YO>JJCUS na VXO=E*G+E))+(N^S$&W,_[LIWZI.K$D[T$@0(1Z;]@=F+
MC02FK8B&L?>2OIEZ48^NI%L>##HVMSMG%>"<OYFJ&=(Q0VR*%C%P">M=?LZD
MP[VG1S_)Y3F.<%(<TI$H$?(O&[IC]"M0K6Y.`I3ZD8:"]7/K,NP2?#[.(\7R
MUFPW78*T8]><5136S$Z29(PQE,9,35[)4*E6S1$@J=/I. Z01G+Q+94.)RS2
M na B38XFJAY'$^FS(ES;!6EFXR,S )-UHN[72"5KP2T9-RS@:TG88[C=HB'SO 
MZ+/G"4J7N/E^NG2T111]-F8)!.+Y0TO_D8[G"D6^[RH=?:JZ"=O80WY&T70$
MP- EU+GO6P^^5H<>@+ na U64K$_?@9I29R;V5(FCU<@1]RR.\8)\E+5"MQNJQ6
M+AK&>V/!LX4M7)LRO!FW#XL?,N na LHA>V>Q-6<E4'149V-^+XNU$/P?SY"AZ<
M#"L&O!GNS=H$'[-ZHED"P3YCG(X2IV=,4%S60=B+9)K$N3"_1DPOKV'7JT0J
MZD0`LEY,CL>!I9K>0#BAY!M3P57$!7F_%KW9UFSLW.$!>)C&$V0\BQ na OV2$"
MA na I88,LPALV>0'=2J\CK#3828G=J#G%<]1<I(*2.SW[Z9/QF-W[>PFZ*AT[1
M, I#Y na -5=-JF[6AT5IPS*.2(XZS&@N1^NP\)GO15^ST?O54#"<#Y8/2?,OM+
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M,86Y,!<X\V'$0HYE`T/\](:5FU8-6KBH2$):UQ]WN65+F'R@`&X&+,>VYH$O
M=/C^8X,$(1UNOEA^@0B*8T4:5POXY%(H@=/ \!Q43<B$E63R9%1=Q_P=#,VK
MC*U @5<?/T(43*D!$'HT]"Z3:<>#@6>*X)]H3N na K(Z/Q#H" \#;ED>5;RC2S
MR13=--FA na +8\?=<8!%R!-2!F40B:XV3?C@/ETQNTL:% HL=>$HUOV5=:GKBL
M4(#YG_O*_Q(JG!KTM1H)@V\)=N na 2ZN5#`XD30-I*L!@X.XX5)OQL>1C6!5\3
MLGQPF,K<<4H],Y^-O,U=EY9G_,:LVE(90+*(IL!30?65O*-P7<KN_!84%[8V
MH0,=IP6H5[ZE$F)1J<A0Y!)'B#9,+/U;A/RNAP-7?,WU25<1SF^NWOW7^ZO;
M%S^KZZN_W/SZXOV/#XW'1MS)3-R".FV,8WP-FH<-:>._IPQUY=6EX4LE2<SO
M<#:(W(-?*EU:<8BGL^=J,AHR#D'%Y&>F(S&689[!M9,[``5;ZQKYP$?%'3GR
M`J(^Y>^B-.R\LDSYTD*@V#/UF[P-""B]`6C_);Y</XW"<.]E%1([LMH@'#^[
MMXCO*B?O:^[=+^SVFB^1X.W2HZJ7KH!H>\E/J#Q*":?H0-=!OW ZD=O[=ST(
M^T2&N\='(P]Y:8\&N)7W]S[M066W^RVGGAQLX >G8\+_,H:FZDR6?,$H<X/Y
ML*092-7;*)>4^],HX na M!=Y4T+C,K$:(RN1WC,2$4<WTR na S* 1-S+^(Y>C"4X
M1(($S8JN]#T'X&#\V$;@/W"SX^@VQE>91QYY'=8<(_)Y)W=AR34BPES6YV?J
M9U2NV!R.2(N]-V?1`G6J06%YO>P5O,;0D:,H.B]V,"](P(N8>U.%2.?O("[P
MZ]_&IG]ZN<#=< @%18E%UTN3\:H"1/\O;R)671-?GPICR<LDF=;.U&T<'4+=
MR]OI1X-<,$!ZL-S('UL==<GD-N)?1HN'850M8<7Q]>E7'+.'D9#II,RA#12S
MZ+OX[PH>/@N=_JJ+W]N?+[B23DZN na J[^O4_UV?A+S_^BAGLG_P8#W.J6YG<0
M#/^I`$<U[D0ZFL=#.VSVHK%J/)N^UWG=X5NB!7!&>^I!/&A>\@?Z>T]FK?UA
M*%.^GQ+6"_%M[TDZR=O5E2UT*CSW,:P0$B#Q`)A!*616AC66EH na 5'B%EA&G_
M!U!+`0(4`!0``@`(`*%CF2SBAPK6?Q(``/TB```&````````````( ``````
>``!-4RYT>'102P4&``````$``0`T````HQ(`````
`
end



Další informace o konferenci Sendmail